A Penny Saved is a Penny Earned... or is it?
In Category: Thoughts
A penny saved is a penny earned
In this festive period we are encouraged to think of others. So, I thought I would write a note for Kate’s excellent Advent blog on the consequences of taking the title concept too far.
Height of umbrage
There was a small feature on the news the other day that mentioned that many of us will experience problems with parcel delivery services this month. Having just had my own issues with UPS claiming to have attempted delivery on a number of occasions when they had made no such attempt; falsifying tracking data to record the fake attempt; and recording the reason for failure as “problems with recipient”, I recognised the issue. After a number of strongly worded emails the item was eventually delivered.
I felt justified in expressing my dissatisfaction with the service and probably was in many respects, but my problems with this service and those many of us will experience in the next few weeks start with the iffy aphorism at the top!
The company from which I ordered this present (not Amazon in this instance) will have taken up a tender from the lowest bidding delivery company. Built into the tender will have been an SLA (Service Level Agreement) that both parties understood would be more honoured in its breach than observance, but would be available to wave around if required in the event of adverse press attention.
That delivery company in turn will employ drivers on terms which contain KPIs (Key Performance Indicators) which are factually impossible to adhere to forcing drivers to take short cuts or, as the excerpt clipped from the BBC website below suggests, risks:
"A BBC investigation has revealed some agency drivers delivering for Amazon drive dangerously because of pressure to finish their rounds on time. An undercover reporter worked long hours for one of the many agencies supplying Amazon with drivers and earned an amount equivalent to less than the minimum wage."
Heart’s not in it….
I am as responsible for the state of affairs I describe as the organisations concerned - and so are you! We all want bargains. We are participants in market competition that forces companies to trade at margins that do not permit levels of service we or they would consider adequate. We are electing to pay for a poor service that inconveniences us and costs us time, energy and money to remedy. We do this because we think we are saving money!
We use and order things from websites and coffee companies that we know do not pay UK taxes. We know this – we logically know that if these companies do not pay their tax we will have to make up the shortfall out of our own pockets, but it does not stop us!
Admission time: almost all of my presents for friends and family this year were ordered from Amazon. Mea culpa, mea maxima culpa. What am I thinking? The shops I did not attend did not receive my money to pay the staff who did not serve me; and neither UK corporate tax nor income taxes were generated by my shopping.
Ultimately my habits and yours’ mean that people are not employed or are under-employed and rely on tax-funded benefits to survive. We work astronomically hard in the UK, mostly to earn enough after tax to live a decent life. Our individual tax burden is huge – there is almost no such thing as after tax because nearly everything we spend our net income on is taxed further.
Why do we cheerfully volunteer to subsidise the profits of Google, Amazon, Apple, Facebook, etc. by paying their taxes for them? Clearly we believe we are saving ourselves some money. These little self-deceptions we allow ourselves are not little they are vast, they affect us; our families; our neighbours; and our society.
I am not about to don a red beret and join the march against globalisation, but having allowed myself to be a part of the problem for a very long time I resolve to think harder about where I spend my money and worry less about whether I am saving a penny and more about the effect of my spending on others.
Now, off to Starbucks…
Every December Leading Light blogger Kate Griffiths-Lambeth invites leading figures from the wider HR industry to contribute thought provoking, powerful articles and commentary to her AdventBlog. Day 19 and Cogence Search's Mark Husband discusses why that 'iffy aphorism', "A penny saved is a a penny earned..." will cause so many of us a deal of heartache this Christmas. http://kategl.blogspot.co.uk/
AdventBlog #AdventBlog #Responsibility #employment
Written by Mark Husband
Survey Results - The Leaky Pipeline
These are the results of our survey of over 12,000 lawyers asked to address questions relevant to the effect of gender on progression in the legal profession. The full article has been published in the October edition of Legal Business Magazine. Cogence Search are a highly specialist London and international Legal Recruitment Agency. Read the full article
THE LEAKY PIPELINE - Gender and Progression in the Legal Profession
Our article addressing the issue of gender and progression in the legal profession based upon an extensive survey involving over 12,000 lawyers. The full survey results can be found in the blog below. Read the full article
Earth Has Not Anything to Show More Fair: London and the Litigation Market
Four London-based dispute resolutions tell us why London is the leading jurisdiction for litigation. ‘The future of London dispute resolution lies in the ability of firms to sell our uniquely global dispute resolution skills to the world.’ Mathew Rea, Bryan Cave Read the full article